{
  "schema": "AIAI_PRODUCT_ORIGINAL_PAIRED_REVIEW_R1",
  "reviewed_at": "2026-10-11T14:11:08.342683+00:00",
  "task_id": "IMAGE_R1_01",
  "reviewer": "Assistant",
  "blinded": false,
  "method": "Direct visual review of four unchanged original outputs; paired by exact frozen prompt",
  "pairs": [
    {
      "prompt_id": "P1",
      "sources": [
        {
          "tool_slug": "adobe-firefly",
          "original_path": "qa/strong200/firefly-product-r1/firefly-original.png",
          "output_sha256": "3026901ca43af020b3be2dc4141d58af4cc0011d5073e949471c1628a6d9248c",
          "model_observed": "Firefly Image 5"
        },
        {
          "tool_slug": "leonardo-ai",
          "original_path": "qa/strong200/limited-lab-r1/leonardo-r1/product-p1-original.jpg",
          "output_sha256": "1d68959f29bacc46d96fb2345db86686d0f1496901ea10944673b2409ecc0c59",
          "model_observed": "Lucid Origin"
        }
      ],
      "finding": "Firefly output closer to explicit soft-light/soft-shadow requirement; Leonardo hard shadow",
      "numeric_rating": null
    },
    {
      "prompt_id": "P2",
      "sources": [
        {
          "tool_slug": "adobe-firefly",
          "original_path": "qa/strong200/limited-lab-r1/firefly-product-p2.png",
          "output_sha256": "74ca5ea1dd6aed7344456d2703e55e00be9608ee772df9652406d2d7c1756c4e",
          "model_observed": "Firefly Image 5"
        },
        {
          "tool_slug": "leonardo-ai",
          "original_path": "qa/strong200/limited-lab-r1/leonardo-r1/product-p2-original.jpg",
          "output_sha256": "1a96a2b6a0b9f16a3d193d9c9743b8b0fa6b4dd8bf723e02e95d247341b32f57",
          "model_observed": "Lucid Origin"
        }
      ],
      "finding": "Firefly output closer to explicit soft-light/soft-shadow requirement; Leonardo hard shadow and multiple window shadow bands",
      "numeric_rating": null
    }
  ],
  "editorial_conclusion_ar": "في عينتي المنتج هاتين، كانت مخرجات Firefly أقرب لشرط الإضاءة والظل الناعمين. التزم Leonardo بظهور المنتج وعدده، لكنه أظهر ظلالًا حادة؛ وفي العطر ظهرت ظلال متعددة لإطار النافذة.",
  "global_winner": null,
  "ranking_authority": false,
  "production_changes": 0,
  "limitations": [
    "Two prompts, one output per tool per prompt; no repeatability estimate",
    "Unblinded: reviewer knew provider identity",
    "Different provider defaults, models and generation times; not a controlled model benchmark",
    "Firefly PNG versus Leonardo native JPEG; no image conversions applied",
    "Completion of original capture does not imply passing visual quality criteria"
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
      "tool_slug": "adobe-firefly",
      "prompt_id": "P1",
      "public_filename": "adobe-firefly-p1.png",
      "output_sha256": "3026901ca43af020b3be2dc4141d58af4cc0011d5073e949471c1628a6d9248c",
      "bytes": 825899,
      "dimensions": [
        1024,
        1024
      ],
      "model_observed": "Firefly Image 5",
      "execution_date": "2026-10-11"
    },
    {
      "tool_slug": "adobe-firefly",
      "prompt_id": "P2",
      "public_filename": "adobe-firefly-p2.png",
      "output_sha256": "74ca5ea1dd6aed7344456d2703e55e00be9608ee772df9652406d2d7c1756c4e",
      "bytes": 879984,
      "dimensions": [
        1024,
        1024
      ],
      "model_observed": "Firefly Image 5",
      "execution_date": "2026-10-11"
    },
    {
      "tool_slug": "leonardo-ai",
      "prompt_id": "P1",
      "public_filename": "leonardo-ai-p1.jpg",
      "output_sha256": "1d68959f29bacc46d96fb2345db86686d0f1496901ea10944673b2409ecc0c59",
      "bytes": 88626,
      "dimensions": [
        1024,
        1024
      ],
      "model_observed": "Lucid Origin",
      "execution_date": "2026-10-11"
    },
    {
      "tool_slug": "leonardo-ai",
      "prompt_id": "P2",
      "public_filename": "leonardo-ai-p2.jpg",
      "output_sha256": "1a96a2b6a0b9f16a3d193d9c9743b8b0fa6b4dd8bf723e02e95d247341b32f57",
      "bytes": 170372,
      "dimensions": [
        1024,
        1024
      ],
      "model_observed": "Lucid Origin",
      "execution_date": "2026-10-11"
    }
  ],
  "public_scope": "Two product prompts only; four original outputs",
  "incremental_monetary_spend": 0
}